THE HOME OF AFGHAN CRICKET FANSAbout Afghan Atalan
Afghan Atalan
ONE NATION.
ONE PASSION.
افغان اتلانPRIDE. PASSION. CRICKET.
Latest news / International Cricket
AFGHANISTAN CRICKET

Hansie Cronje scandal voted Test cricket’s biggest controversy

Hansie Cronje’s match-fixing scandal has been voted the biggest controversy in Test cricket history, ahead of the Basil D’Oliveira affair and Australia’s 2018 ball-tampering scandal, in a poll conducted by Test Match Special and BBC Sport readers.

2026-10-07

Hansie Cronje scandal voted Test cricket’s biggest controversy

Hansie Cronje’s match-fixing scandal has been ranked the greatest controversy in Test cricket history, according to a poll conducted by Test Match Special and BBC Sport readers.

The result was revealed on the TMS podcast by BBC chief cricket commentator Jonathan Agnew, former England fast bowler Steven Finn and scorer Andy Zaltzman, ahead of Australia’s first Test in South Africa since the 2018 Cape Town ball-tampering scandal.

Cronje, South Africa’s former captain, admitted taking money from Indian bookmakers. His most notorious offence came during the rain-affected fifth Test against England at Centurion Park in 2000. With the match heading towards a draw, Cronje negotiated with England captain Nasser Hussain for both sides to forfeit an innings, creating a final-day chase that England completed. Hussain was unaware Cronje had arranged the result for corrupt purposes.

The scandal emerged after Delhi police, attempting to intercept a bookmaker’s telephone, accidentally recorded a conversation involving Cronje. Agnew described the revelation as a shock that led to important changes, while Zaltzman said the deal had initially appeared to be an imaginative way to create a contest in a dead rubber.

Second in the voting was the Basil D’Oliveira affair of 1968. England’s tour of South Africa was cancelled after the inclusion of the mixed-race all-rounder became a major issue during the apartheid era. Agnew linked the controversy to the eventual emergence of a new South Africa, while Zaltzman said it exposed the pressure placed on D’Oliveira and the English cricket establishment.

Sandpapergate, involving Australia’s Cameron Bancroft, Steve Smith and David Warner during the 2018 Test against South Africa in Cape Town, was third. Bancroft was caught on camera using sandpaper to alter the ball, a decision Finn called astonishing in an era of extensive television coverage.

England’s Bodyline tactics during the 1932-33 Ashes were fourth. England used hostile short-pitched bowling aimed at Australia’s batters, with Harold Larwood’s delivery striking wicketkeeper Bert Oldfield in the head during the Adelaide Test. Pakistan’s 2010 spot-fixing scandal completed the top five; captain Salman Butt and fast bowlers Mohammad Asif and Mohammad Amir were jailed after deliberate no-balls were bowled in the Lord’s Test.

The remaining controversies included Michael Atherton’s 1994 Lord’s ball-tampering incident, when he was filmed applying dirt to the ball; Kerry Packer’s World Series Cricket, which recruited leading players for privately organised matches; the 1975 Headingley Test, abandoned after the pitch was vandalised by supporters of jailed armed robber George Davis; the 1987 dispute between England captain Mike Gatting and Pakistani umpire Shakoor Rana, which halted play for more than 24 hours; and the 2006 Oval Test.

In that match, umpire Darrell Hair ordered the ball changed after suspecting Pakistan of tampering. Pakistan refused to resume after tea, and the abandoned Test was eventually awarded to England, giving them a 3-0 series victory and producing a 331-run first-innings deficit overturned into a win.

EN پښتو